Electric vs Gas Grill: Which Is Right for You?

This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.

Do you intend to use your grill for cooking in any weather? Or just for outdoor meals on sunny days?

This is just one of the many factors to consider when deciding between electric vs gas grill.

Both have distinct features, pros, and cons that make one better (or worse) than the other.

To help you decide, let’s take a close look at what each one has to offer.

Electric vs Gas Grill: Where Do They Differ?

While both options offer exceptional ease of use, certain factors set them aside.

Here is where a gas grill vs electric grill differs:

1. Fuel Source

Do you prefer grilling your meats on an open flame or over a heat source that uses electricity?

Gas

Gas grills either use propane or natural gas, both of which are more eco-friendly than using charcoal.

Between the two, which is better for gas grills?

Propane gas supplies more heat than natural gas, so it grills your food faster.

The problem is, you will have to stock up on propane tanks to ensure you always have some available when you need it.

Doing so is also dangerous, especially if there is a leakage.

While it will increase your gas bill, running a grill on natural gas is still more practical and cost-effective.

However, keep in mind that a gas grill connected to your home’s gas line won’t be portable like one that runs on a propane tank.

Electric

As the name implies, electric grills make use of electricity as their fuel source.

This allows you to grill outdoors or indoors, as long as there is an electric outlet nearby.

Most portable electric grills feature a short power cord, though, limiting you to using it only for indoor grilling.

If you are going camping or need a portable option, then an electric grill would be ideal.

When it comes to operational costs, having an electric grill means you won’t need to shell out money to buy and store gas tanks.

However, you also have to remember its impact on your energy bill.

2. Size

The number of people you intend to feed is a major consideration to put into account before choosing between an electric grill vs gas grill.

Electric

Electric grills are usually small in size, with the largest one being on the same size level as the smallest gas grills.

What you will love about this is that you will only need at least two square feet of space for storage.

Because of their smaller size, electric grills are also easily portable.

Gas

Gas grills come in different sizes, ranging from small to large.

Often, you will find larger gas grills in big restaurants because they can feed more than a hundred.

You would need at least six feet of space, a workstation, and side burners for an average-sized gas grill.

If you love having outdoor family picnics or just enjoy meals in your backyard, the gas grill is more suitable for you.

3. Temperature Range

Besides the size and fuel source, you will also have to consider the temperature range when choosing between a gas grill vs an electric grill.

Electric

Generally speaking, you can expect an electric grill to heat up quickly and then shuts off when it reaches the set temperature.

Then, it will heat up again, either following a timer or when the temperature drops.

For this reason, you can’t rely on it to sear food evenly or do other tasks that require intense radiant heat for long periods.

Even so, it’s not entirely useless. You can use it for low-temperature grilling as well as for reheating.

Gas

You will have a wider range of temperatures when cooking with a gas grill.

Maintaining a high degree is also easier, even for long periods.

The problem is, it won’t work as well as its counterpart when you use it for low-temperature grilling (roughly 225F to 250F).

On the brighter side, a gas grill will be exceptional for searing.

All you have to do is set the temperature at a high enough level and grill effortlessly.

4. Cooking Capacity

Your choice would also depend on the size of the cooking surface.

Electric

No matter how hard you try to find an electric grill with a large cooking capacity, you wouldn’t.

So, don’t expect to cater for a neighborhood picnic or backyard barbeque gathering with over a hundred guests with an electric grill.

Electric grills are perfect for small family dinners or maybe a picnic with 10 to 15 guests.

Gas

On the other hand, gas grills come in various sizes; they can be anything from small to monstrous.

You can opt for a compact unit if you just need it for casual outdoor dinners.

However, if you need over 500 square inches of cooking space, then a bigger gas grill is your best bet.

5. Reliability

This category of gas grills vs electric grill pretty much boils down to your budget.

Many highly trusted companies make electric and gas grills.

You just have to go with a reputable brand to minimize your grill’s chances of developing a fault sooner rather than later.

Electric

In case of repairs, electric grills are not easy to fix, especially if the thermostat becomes faulty.

Gas

If anything happens to a gas grill, having it repaired is cheaper because its parts can easily be replaced.

difference between electric vs gas grill

6. Cleaning and Storage

Cleaning, maintenance, and proper storage of your grill play a major role in its durability.

Electric

Electric grills cannot be submerged in water because their components include coils and cables.

Alternatively, you can use a damp cloth to clean the outer surface.

You will find electric grills with non-stick surfaces, too, making them very easy and convenient to clean.

Be sure always to inspect the wiring of your electric grill to prevent any form of accident.

After use, ensure you store it inside the cabinets.

Maintaining an electric grill is a piece of cake; just ensure you keep it dry and clean.

Gas

After every use, you can disassemble its removable parts and soak them in water for cleaning.

With a gas grill, you must also consider the storage of the propane tank connected to it.

Ensure you keep it in a place with enough space to avoid leaks and tears because propane tanks are prone to explosions.

A gas grill may sound a bit more complicated in terms of maintenance, but it really isn’t; electric grills are just less tasking.

With a gas grill, make sure to always check the connections, the burners are tightly secured, and watch out for spider webs, which can sometimes be in the tubes.

7. Popularity

Gas grills are very popular, but does that make it the best choice?

Electric

The electric grill is continuously gaining popularity because of its convenience and efficiency.

It fits easily into the modern lifestyle, but there isn’t a large group of communities to run to for help or support your journey.

Gas

Gas grills come in different sizes and shapes and are suitable for both small and large families.

There are lots of social media groups you can turn to for advice.

In general, gas grills are more popular and have a wider range of selection than electric grills.

8. Quality of Food

Because electric vs gas grill uses different fuel sources, the quality of the result differs, too.

Gas

Gas grills use open heat, so it automatically gives the smokey barbeque flavor.

As you may have guessed, this is a type of flavor you cannot get with electric grills.

Electric

On that same note, an electric grill has its perk.

You can easily maintain its heat because it holds low temperatures well.

With an electric grill, flare-ups would rarely occur, making your food cook at a consistent temperature.

Electric Grill vs Gas Grill Summary

A lot of homeowners utilize gas grills because of their versatility. Then again, electric grills offer many advantages, too.

Are you ready to make a move and purchase your first electric or gas grill?

Breeze through the pros and cons listed below to decide.

Electric Grill Pros

  • Perfect grill for the summer and winter season
  • Zero gas leaks
  • Never runs out of fuel
  • Minimal maintenance
  • Ease of use
  • For outdoor and indoor use
  • Requires less storage space

Electric Grill Cons

  • Searing of food is impossible
  • Can’t operate without electricity
  • Cannot be washed in water
  • Hard to find a model with a large cooking capacity

Gas Grill Pros

  • All components are washable
  • Gives food a smoky taste
  • More energy efficient
  • Heats up quickly
  • Has more grilling options

Gas Grill Cons

  • Requires more maintenance
  • Natural gas is on the pricey side
  • Not portable compared to electric grills

Are Electric Grills Better Than Gas?

The answer to this depends on your priority.

Both electric and gas grills offer different experiences.

For some, if given enough space to keep them, they would always go for gas grills.

Though they require more maintenance, that is a small price to pay to achieve that smokey taste we all know and love about grilled meats.

Then again, those who enjoy grilling indoors can only do so with the use of an electric grill.

Are Electric Grills Worth It?

Are electric grills good investments?

Yes, of course. Electric grills can be a rewarding investment and a healthy choice.

It melts off the fat of large chunks of meat, which then drips off onto a removable tray.

On the other hand, if you are to ask: are electric grills good for searing or roasting? Unfortunately, the answer is no.

Do Electric Grills Use a Lot of Electricity?

No, they don’t. However, this is subject to change if you are using them for an extended period.

If you know that you will use your grill several times a week and for large cooking, you may want to go for gas grills instead.

What Type of Grill Is Healthiest?

Compared to other types of grilling, gas grilling takes the crown here.

The reason is that the heat emanated doesn’t contain or release harmful compounds into your food.

But there is a twist!

When it comes to the healthiest way to grill, we have to give it to electric grills.

Because it doesn’t use unsustainable gas that is harmful to the environment, it is your best option if health is a major concern.

Conclusion

A gas grill vs electric grill both have unique features, so the choice boils down to your personal preference and lifestyle.

Gas grills are perfect for those who want a very big cooking area for large barbeque picnics.

Also, if you love that authentic smoky flavor, the gas grill is for you.

If you want a portable grill and prefer a grill for indoor use, you should go for an electric unit.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Special offer for our visitors

Get your Patio & Outdoor Free Guide

We will never send you spam. By signing up for this you agree with our privacy policy and to receive regular updates via email in regards to industry news and promotions